Daniel and Donna Hill raised three children: Daniel (or Dan), born in 1954 in Toronto; Lawrence (or Larry), born in 1957 in Newmarket; and Karen, born in 1958 in Newmarket.  

In 1956, Daniel and Donna moved to Newmarket to buy their first home, a small bungalow where they remained until 1962. At that time, when their children were still quite young, they moved to Don Mills, where Donna remains in the family home.

Don Mills is currently a multi-racial Toronto suburb, but in the early 1960s its inhabitants were almost entirely White.  Raising an interracial family in Don Mills came as quite a change for Daniel and Donna, who were accustomed to living in an environment that was highly charged, racially, in the United States. 

Although all of their children’s cousins, on Daniel’s side of the family, were considered Black in the United States-indeed, some had no choice but to attend segregated schools-Dan, Larry and Karen grew up in a state of some ambiguity. At some moments, other children in the schools or on the streets of Don Mills reminded the Hill children in the rudest ways of their Black ancestry. At other times, peers expressed disbelief that the young Hill children had any Black heritage at all. It took Dan, Larry and Karen some time to settle into a clear, confident sense of their Black heritage and of their dual ancestral identities.  Eventually, they each developed an interest in literature and in creative expression, as a way of making sense of the world and their own place in it.

Daniel Hill III anxiously and repeatedly urged his children to become doctors, lawyers and engineers, but his urgings were for naught. Each of the children was interested primarily in the arts-and it was through the arts that the children publicly demonstrated how much they loved their parents.

Their eldest child, Daniel Hill IV, dropped out of school at the age of 17 to become a singer-songwriter, and went on to sell millions of records around the world.  Lawrence became a novelist and journalist, and Karen wrote many poems and stories.  Each of the three children-who are now adults with nearly adult-age children of their own-continues to write creatively. And each has written tributes to their father or mother, or both.

One of Dan Hill IV ’s early songs was McCarthy’s Day, a tribute to the interracial marriage that his parents forged. Dan wrote the song in 1973, when he was nineteen years old. McCarthy’s Day appeared on Dan’s third album, Longer Fuse, in 1977.  The title “McCarthy’s Day” is a reference to the Joseph McCarthy, an American Republican senator from Wisconsin who in the 1950s conducted aggressive and damaging investigations against Americans who were suspected of being communists or communist sympathizers. In the eyes of Daniel Hill III and Donna Bender Hill, McCarthy represented the very worst of American intolerance and demagogy. McCarthy’s most active anti-communist investigations were conducted from 1950-1954, the same period in which Daniel Hill III and Donna Bender met and married.

McCarthy’s Day by Dan Hill

This is just a song to say
That i'm proud for what they are
And i hope my world can take me
Half that far

Way back in mccarthy's day
My parents left the usa
Young rebellious lovers
They left behind a nation far too proud
And powerful to say
That love transcends all colors
Some black men turned against my father
Some white men turned against my mother
Each race has their place they all would say

And with a past so battle worn
And a future begging to be born
They found a life that's growing still today

And glancing thru the years
And living thru their fears
I hope they can accept my goals
A bit confused, a bit unclear

“McCarthy’s Day”, composed and sung by Dan Hill IV, McCauley Music Ltd.,1976
Used with the permission of Dan Hill IV and Matthew McCauley of McCaule Music Ltd.

Lawrence Hill became a novelist, non-fiction writer and journalist, and has written often about his parents in his published writings. In his memoir Black Berry, Sweet Juice: On Being Black and White in Canada (HarperCollins Canada, 2001), Lawrence Hill wrote about how his parents met and married, and about the predominant social values at the time.

Book cover of “Black Berry, Sweet Juice:
On Being Black and White in Canada”,
by Lawrence Hill, Published by
HarperCollins Canada Ltd., 2001
Courtesy of Lawrence Hill

To Read the chapter "I Wouldn't Have to
Educate Her," click here.

Karen Hill has written many stories and poems, and in some of them pays her creative tribute to Daniel Hill III. After Daniel Hill died in 2003, Karen Hill wrote “A Breath of You” and read it aloud at her father’s memorial service, where more than a thousand people who cared for Daniel Hill came to pay tribute to him at the Metropolitan United Church in Toronto.

Click to see a larger image (370K)
Daniel G. Hill Jr. and May Edwards Hill 50th wedding anniversary, 1967
Daniel G. Hill fonds
Reference Code: F 2130-9-2-6.1
Archives of Ontario, I0027967